Chicago is famous for its deep-dish pizza, but the city’s culinary landscape boasts a plethora of hidden gems serving incredible pies that often go unnoticed. For pizza lovers eager to explore beyond the typical tourist hotspots, these underrated establishments offer unique takes on this beloved dish. This blog post takes a deep dive into the lesser-known pizzerias across Chicago that serve the best pizza, celebrating creative crusts, innovative toppings, and authentic flavors. Each location presents an opportunity for locals and visitors alike to indulge in Chicago’s rich pizza culture in a refreshing way.
Join us as we unveil the hidden gems that promise delightful flavors and extraordinary dining experiences, proving that in a city renowned for its iconic deep-dish, there’s an astonishing array of pizza options waiting to be discovered. From artisanal slices to innovative flavor combinations, these spots redefine what pizza means in Chicago. Get ready to elevate your pizza experience as we explore these culinary treasures.
Table of Contents
- Luminaria Pizza
- Pequod’s Pizza
- Coalfire Pizza
- Labriola Baking Company
- Golden Slice
- Famous Dave’s Bar-B-Que
Luminaria Pizza
Situated in the heart of Lincoln Park, Luminaria Pizza is an absolute paradise for pizza enthusiasts craving something different. This charming eatery is known for its wood-fired pies, which are skillfully crafted using high-quality, locally sourced ingredients. One taste of their signature Margherita will make you appreciate the delightful balance of fresh tomatoes, creamy mozzarella, and fragrant basil. This pizza embodies what authentic Italian cuisine stands for. Moreover, Luminaria does not shy away from innovative toppings; their spicy aioli drizzle elevates any selection, transforming traditional flavors into culinary masterpieces.
Equally impressive is the restaurant’s cozy, rustic vibe that invites patrons to linger and savor their meals. A wood-burning oven serves as the centerpiece, creating an atmosphere that enhances your dining experience. Pair your pizza with one of their artisan cocktails or a craft beer from a local brewery to complete the experience. Luminaria Pizza isn’t just a meal; it’s an experience that tantalizes the taste buds and creates memories that linger long after the last slice is gone.
Pequod’s Pizza
If you haven’t heard about Pequod’s Pizza, you’re missing out on one of Chicago’s best-kept secrets. Located in Lincoln Park and Morton Grove, this establishment is renowned for specializing in deep-dish pizza with a twist. What sets Pequod’s apart is its caramelized crust, a unique innovation that creates a crunchy, flavorful base, truly elevating the deep-dish pizza game. Diners rave about the dish’s rich flavor, bursting with toppings of your choice, whether it’s traditional pepperoni or a medley of fresh vegetables. Each pie is crafted with a meticulous attention to detail, ensuring that every slice brings forth an explosion of taste.
The ambiance at Pequod’s is eclectic and warm, making it a perfect spot for both casual gatherings and family dinners. The distinctively intimate decor adds a charming touch to your pizza experience. Moreover, don’t overlook their extensive menu of appetizers and salads, which perfectly complement your main course. Discovering Pequod’s feels like finding a hidden treasure in the city, and it reminds diners that there’s always more to explore in Chicago’s culinary scene.
Coalfire Pizza
Coalfire Pizza is another gem worth featuring on this list, located in the vibrant suburbs of Chicago. Their specialty lies in coal-fired pizzas, which means they utilize a secret method of cooking at extremely high temperatures, creating crusts that boast a crispy exterior while remaining pliable and deliciously chewy on the inside. Customers are constantly delighted by their variety of pizzas, particularly the “Margherita” and “Spicy Sausage,” both crafted from the finest ingredients to provide a burst of flavors that leaves a lasting impression.
The modern yet relaxed environment at Coalfire provides the perfect backdrop for an enjoyable meal with friends or family. With an inviting atmosphere and an impressive selection of craft beers, every dining experience here makes you feel right at home. If you’re seeking a pizzeria that embraces its historical roots while pushing the boundaries of traditional pizza-making techniques, Coalfire Pizza will not disappoint. Stop by for a truly memorable pizza experience that highlights the art and craft of this beloved dish.
Labriola Baking Company
Labriola Baking Company in Chicago is more than just a pizzeria; it’s a gourmet culinary experience that combines freshly baked bread with the artistry of pizza-making. Labriola’s commitment to high-quality ingredients shines through in every bite. Their acclaimed Neapolitan-style pizzas are made using time-honored techniques that deliver a remarkable crust—thin, airy, and slightly charred, reminiscent of the streets of Naples. They are particularly known for their unique toppings, such as the Gruyere and smoked mozzarella combination, which brings an unconventional yet delightful twist to traditional pizza.
The atmosphere at Labriola is quite inviting, featuring an open kitchen where the magic happens right before your eyes. Witnessing the skilled chefs craft your pizza adds to the unique dining experience. Pair your handmade pizza with a selection from their impressive wine list for the perfect meal. The appreciation for artisanal baking and thoughtful ingredient choices make Labriola a must-visit for anyone serious about their pizza in Chicago.
Golden Slice
Golden Slice provides a fresh take on pizza, with their artisanal, hand-tossed pies that cater to various dietary preferences including vegan and gluten-free options. Located in the trendy neighborhood of Wicker Park, this pizzeria prioritizes quality ingredients and sustainability in its sourcing. Their signature “Golden Special” features a dynamic blend of house-made sauces and creative toppings, proving that pizza can be both delicious and healthy.
The atmosphere at Golden Slice is modern and welcoming, with a colorful decor that reflects the vibrant community surrounding it. It fosters an inclusive environment where anyone, regardless of dietary restrictions, can indulge in quality pizza. This pizzeria isn’t just about food; it’s about community and promoting healthy dining habits while celebrating the love of pizza. A visit here guarantees a slice of something special that will have you coming back for more.
Famous Dave’s Bar-B-Que
While primarily known for its mouthwatering barbecue, Famous Dave’s Bar-B-Que offers some surprising pizza options that are worth trying. Their unique twist includes barbecue sauce as a base, starting with their “Barbecue Chicken Pizza,” which encapsulates both smoky and sweet flavors in a single slice. Not only does this inventive approach separate them from conventional pizza joints, but it also reflects the culinary diversity that Chicago blindly embraces. The juxtaposition of flavors and textures makes dining here a delightful adventure.
The casual atmosphere and lively decor make it an inviting spot for families and groups, where laughter and good food coexist. By embracing unconventional ingredients and recipes, Famous Dave’s elevates the pizza experience and challenges traditional notions of what pizza can be. It’s a must-visit for anyone wanting to experience a fusion of barbecue and pizza like never before.
Explore Chicago’s Pizza Scene
Chicago’s pizza scene extends well beyond the famous deep-dish offerings available at widespread pizzerias. These hidden gems not only challenge conventional perceptions of pizza but also continually reinvent the dish, showcasing creativity and innovation. Each restaurant mentioned includes a specific ambiance and unique menu options that cater to a variety of pizza lovers’ tastes. So whether you’re a local or visiting the Windy City, don’t hesitate to venture beyond the typical pizza places, as you discover gems that elevate this iconic dish into an unforgettable culinary experience. The beauty of exploring these eateries lies in the surprises that await; you’ll end up wanting to visit each multiple times.
Frequently Asked Questions
- What is the best pizzeria for deep-dish pizza in Chicago?
The definitive deep-dish pizza experience can be found at Pequod’s Pizza, known for its uniquely caramelized crust. - Are there gluten-free pizza options available in Chicago?
Golden Slice offers an excellent selection of gluten-free pizza, ensuring that everyone can enjoy a slice. - Can I find vegan pizza options in Chicago?
Absolutely! Many pizzerias like Golden Slice cater to vegan diets, creating delicious pizzas that everyone can enjoy. - What toppings make the best pizza in Chicago?
Unique combinations such as smoked mozzarella or creative BBQ sauces can elevate your pizza experience—try them at Labriola Baking Company and Famous Dave’s Bar-B-Que.
Image Credit: Pexels
